The 2026 NFL coaching carousel brought several high-profile hires, with a mix of excitement, skepticism, and anticipation. While it’s impossible to know right away how each new head coach and coordinator will perform, we can still assess their potential and the fit with their respective teams. Here’s a look at the recent hires, with grades reflecting both the immediate impact and long-term outlook for each appointment.
*This post will be updated as new hires are made.*
Head Coaching Hires
New York Giants: John Harbaugh
The Giants hit a home run with the hiring of John Harbaugh, who is widely regarded as one of the top coaches available this cycle. With a Super Bowl victory under his belt and a career winning percentage of 61.4%, Harbaugh brings a wealth of experience to a team desperate for stability. His tenure with the Baltimore Ravens has been marked by consistency, and while the Giants may not see immediate playoff success, Harbaugh’s leadership and proven track record make him the best hire they’ve made since Tom Coughlin.
Grade: A+
Atlanta Falcons: Kevin Stefanski
Kevin Stefanski’s hiring by the Falcons is an intriguing one, as he brings with him two NFL Coach of the Year awards and a solid track record in Cleveland. Despite the challenges in his previous role, Stefanski is known for his ability to navigate quarterback uncertainty and maximize the potential of his team. With a talented roster in a weak division, he is well-positioned to lead the Falcons to immediate improvement. Stefanski’s experience, paired with his ability to develop a quarterback, makes this an excellent move for Atlanta.
Grade: A
Miami Dolphins: Jeff Hafley
The Dolphins secured Jeff Hafley after his successful stint as the Green Bay Packers’ defensive coordinator. While Miami faces some significant challenges, including a potential quarterback overhaul and a salary cap crunch, Hafley’s previous head-coaching experience at Boston College provides a strong foundation for his transition to the NFL. The Dolphins will need patience as Hafley works to build a competitive team, but this hiring signals a long-term strategy.
Grade: B
Tennessee Titans: Robert Saleh
Robert Saleh brings strong defensive credentials to the Titans, following a successful stint as the San Francisco 49ers’ defensive coordinator. Despite a rough head-coaching record with the New York Jets, Saleh’s leadership and ability to rebuild a defense will be a major asset to a Titans team that has struggled in recent seasons. His next big challenge will be shaping an offensive staff capable of supporting Tennessee’s No. 1 pick in the 2025 NFL Draft, quarterback Cam Ward.
Grade: B+
Coordinator Hires
Detroit Lions Offensive Coordinator: Drew Petzing
Drew Petzing’s hire as offensive coordinator for the Detroit Lions brings some intrigue, especially given his previous work with the Arizona Cardinals. Though the Cardinals’ offense struggled under his watch, there were extenuating circumstances, such as inconsistent quarterback play. Now, with a more talented Lions offense at his disposal, Petzing has the opportunity to succeed. His connection with former Lions offensive coordinator Ben Johnson may also help him settle into the role, but the pressure is on to deliver results quickly.
Grade: B-
Los Angeles Chargers Offensive Coordinator: Mike McDaniel
The Chargers have made a strong move by hiring Mike McDaniel as their offensive coordinator. Known for his innovative offensive schemes and previous head-coaching interest, McDaniel is poised to take the Chargers’ offense to new heights. With a star quarterback in Justin Herbert and an improving offensive line, McDaniel’s play-calling expertise should elevate the Chargers into one of the top offensive units in the league.
Grade: A
